Our Favorite Comforter Sets For Every Budget

Our Favorite Comforter Sets For Every Budget


Whether you lean into matchy-matching or err on the side of eclectic, comforter sets do the heavy lifting to anchor the space and pull the details of your bedroom together. But, like everything else, finding the best comforter set is easier said than done. 

Hafiz Shariff, sleep expert and founder of Owl + Lark says, “When buying a comforter, you should carefully consider factors like the material (such as cotton, down, or synthetic fill), fill power (the measure of fluffiness for down comforters), weight, and size.”

Beyond the usual suspects, Shariff adds, “that checking for hypoallergenic properties, ease of maintenance, and the overall comfort level” are important checklist items for finding a comforter set you can enjoy for years to come. 

We researched the best comforter sets and evaluated them based on material, the number of pieces included, care, and more. 

What’s included in a comforter set?

Most comforter sets will include a comforter and two shams (one for twin). You may also find sets with coordinating bed skirts, bed sheets, and extra pillows. If you’re looking to build your bedding from scratch, a comforter set eliminates the need to find individual bedding items that go together.

Sleep Number Classic Down Alternative

Sleep Number 


What’s Great About It

  • Hypoallergenic fill offers down-like comfort without the irritation

  • All-season use

  • Machine washable and dryer friendly

  • 100-night guarantee

  • Sewn-through construction keeps the fill from shifting

Promising all-season comfort, this lightweight comforter set is crafted from 100% cotton sateen fabric and stuffed with hypoallergenic polyester fill for plenty of “down-like” comfort—just without the smell and post-nasal drip.

“Down-alternative comforters offer the same soft, cozy, and lightweight feel as a traditional down-filled comforter but without the potential allergens,” says Isabella Gordon, a Sleep Science Coach and co-founder of Sleep Society. For those who prefer to breathe freely while they sleep, Sleep Number’s Classic Down Alternative is an excellent hypoallergenic pinch-hit for allergy-causing feathers. 

The set is machine washable, and the sewn-through box construction keeps the fill from shifting so it remains soft and lofty no matter how many times you run it through the wash. 

Each set comes with a comforter and two shams. You can choose from 10 colors; solids and prints reverse to same; textured comforters reverse to a solid.

Overall, Sleep Number’s Classic Down Alternative is light and lofty, and while it keeps you warm, there’s no need to worry about overheating. And if you’re still on the fence, this comforter set comes with the Sleep Number’s 100-night guarantee—if you do not love it, you can return or exchange it.

Pieces Included: 1 comforter, 2 shams | Material: Cotton, polyester fill | Sizes: Twin-California king | Care: Machine wash, tumble dry

Bare Home Comforter Set

Amazon


What’s Great About It

  • Right weight for year-round use

  • Comes in over two dozen color options

  • Machine washable and dryer friendly

  • Low price point

With Bare Home’s Comforter Set, you’re looking at a comforter and two shams for less than $55—sounds pretty budget-friendly to us. Made from 100% microfiber with polyester fiberfill, this comforter set is super soft and infinitely stylish. And while it’s lightweight and insulated enough to guard against a chill on a frosty February night, the down alternative is breathable enough for year-round use. 

Bare Home’s comforter set is machine washable and dryer friendly. It’s wrinkle-, fade-, and stain-resistant, and the box stitching guards against shifting and bunching.

We’ll add here that this comforter set by Bare Home is a budget option, so the decorative possibilities are limited. It’s available in 26 colors, including solids and reversible plaids, but anyone looking for fun prints won’t find it here.

Pieces Included: 1 comforter, 2 shams | Material: Microfiber with poly fiber fill | Sizes: Twin/twin XL-oversized king | Care: Machine wash, tumble dry or air dry

Casaluna Heavyweight Linen Blend Comforter & Sham Set

Target


What’s Great About It

  • Crisp and airy linen blend

  • Cotton sateen backing for comfort

  • Over a dozen color options

  • Machine washable and dryer friendly

Linen tops the shortlist for a lot of folks because it’s breathable, crisp, and infinitely elegant. Checking all of those boxes and then some, we chose Casaluna Heavyweight Linen Blend Comforter & Sham Set from Target as our best linen comforter set. 

This comforter blends linen with rayon for an incredibly soft topside and graceful drape, while a 100% cotton sateen backing adds a luxe finish that feels comfortable against your skin. So while it’s a heavyweight comforter, it still looks and feels light, natural, and airy, making it an excellent choice for hot sleepers. Ultimately, it’s comfy enough for year-round use, and we’re sure you will be delighted with modern color options like dark gray, moss green, and terracotta. 

This set comes with a comforter and two pillow shams. While this comforter is machine washable, it’s still linen and quite heavy. So while you can run it through a wash cycle at home, small drums might be an issue, and this comforter may require multiple drying cycles before finding its way back to your bed.

Pieces Included: 1 comforter, 2 shams | Material: 70% rayon, 30% linen, polyester fill, cotton backing | Sizes: Twin/twin XL-king/California king | Care: Machine wash, tumble dry

Rose Tree Harrogate Paisley Damask & Geometric Diamond Comforter Set

Wayfair


We spend about one-third of our lives sleeping, so if there’s any place to double down on something luxurious, your bed is probably it. With this Rose Tree Harrogate Paisley Damask & Geometric Comforter Set, you can give your bedroom a stylish upgrade. 

Featuring a comforter, two shams, and a bed skirt, you’ll have everything you need for a restful night of sleep. Both the comforters and the shams are reversible, featuring a paisley damask pattern on one side and a geometric diamond pattern on the other. Both have a metallic gold corded trim reminiscent of old Holywood. And best of all, both are machine washable. 

The comforter comes oversized to fit a pillow-top mattress, but we do wish it came in more than just queen and king sizes. Rose Tree offers an assortment of matching accent pillows to fit the set, too. 

Pieces Included: 1 comforter, 2 shams,1 bed skirt | Material: Cotton, polyester | Sizes: Queen and king | Care: Machine wash

Calvin Klein Washed Percale Comforter & Shams Set

Wayfair


What’s Great About It

  • Smooth, garment-washed cotton percale

  • Material becomes softer with each wash

  • 200-thread count allows for plenty of airflow

  • Medium weight

  • Easy to clean

Whenever you’re trying to elevate your sleep experience, it’s hard to go wrong with crisp cotton bedding. And, this percale cotton comforter set comes garment washed for maximum softness and will continue to soften with each wash.

The comforter comes in five neutral colors, each of which has a knife-edge finish for a put-together look. The 200-thread-count percale weave allows for plenty of airflow, and it’s a nice medium weight for all-season use. 

What’s more, it’s machine washable and dryer friendly for easy cleanup. However, we do wish it came in more than just queen and king sizes. 

Pieces Included: 1 comforter, 2 shams | Material: Cotton, polyester fill | Sizes: Queen, king | Care: Machine wash, tumble dry

UGG Blissful Comforter Set

Amazon


What’s Great About It

  • Cozy but lightweight and suitable for use year-round

  • Plush faux shearling reverses to a soft microfleece

  • Hypoallergenic down-alternative fill

When buying comforter sets for cold weather, Gordon suggests looking for thick materials. And while down or wool often steal the show, anyone who’s ever cuddled up with faux shearling can tell you it’s just as cozy.

This Ugg comforter set is a must-have for chilly winter nights. The plush faux shearling reverses to a soft microfleece, and a hypoallergenic down-alternative fill doubles down on the warmth. 

This comforter set includes a comforter and two standard shams. We should note that while faux shearling and fleece make it sound like this comforter is limited to fall and winter usage, it’s pretty lightweight, so it’s equally useful when you have to crank up the AC during the dog days of summer.

Pieces Included: 1 comforter, 2 shams | Material: Polyester | Sizes: Full/queen-king | Care: Machine wash, tumble dry low

Bedsure Spring Bedding Pintuck Comforter Set

Bedsure


What’s Great About It

  • Brushed microfiber is machine washable and dryer friendly

  • Chic pinch pleats in a geometric pattern

  • More than two dozen colors

Keeping your bedding fresh is crucial, especially when you factor in kids and pets. Bedsure makes it all so easy with their machine-washable and dryer-friendly comforter set. 

This comforter is made with brushed microfiber, so it’s soft and cozy, and even with repeated washing, it doesn’t fade, shrink, or otherwise come apart. Pinch pleats in a geometric pattern look super chic on any bed, and with a microfiber-filling blend, this comforter offers a nice balance of weight and warmth. 

Each set comes with a comforter, a flat sheet, a fitted sheet, two pillow shams, and two pillowcases. And with sizes ranging from twin to California king and over two dozen color choices, the mix-and-match options are endless. 

It’s worth noting that we had to take a few points away because the dimensions of the queen comforter are a bit short (88 by 88 inches), so anyone who wants a longer drape should probably size up. Also, while the pinch pleats can disguise wrinkles, they can only do so much, so you might want to take these out of the dryer as soon as the buzzer goes off.

Included Pieces: 1 comforter, 1 sheet set, 2 pillow shams | Material: Microfiber | Sizes: Twin-California King | Care: Machine wash, tumble dry 

Downluxe Reversible Comforter Set

Amazon


What’s Great About It

  • Available in nearly 40 colors and patterns, all reversible

  • Medium weight

  • Machine washable and dryer friendly

With nearly 40 colors and patterns, the Downluxe Reversible Comforter Set hits our list as the most versatile. Whether your idea of the perfect bed is black on black pinch pleats or a blue plaid that reverses to solid navy, you’ll find it here. 

This bedding set is made of 100% brushed microfiber, so it’s incredibly soft and comfortable against your skin, and the down-alternative microfiber filling is plush and comfy night after night. 

The Downluxe comforter is medium-weight and quite warm. And while it may not be the best choice when the mercury takes a chilly nosedive, you can probably get away with this one for most of the year. 

This set comes with a reversible comforter and two reversible pillow shams (one for twin). Plus, it’s machine washable, and the box stitching keeps the microfiber fill in place, even through the most rigorous spin cycle.

Pieces Included: 1 comforter, 2 pillow shams | Material: Microfiber | Sizes: Twin-king | Care:  Machine wash, tumble dry

Pottery Barn Kids Daydreamer Comforter & Shams

Pottery Barn Kids 


What’s Great About It

  • Colors are bright but subdued enough to keep decor options open

  • Hand quilted

  • Grid pattern keeps the filling from shifting

  • Machine washable and dryer friendly

While most kids’ bedding is plastered with the usual suspects like the solar system, dinosaurs, and unicorns, those designs can limit the room decor possibilities to primary colors. Parents looking for something a bit different can soften things up with the Pottery Barn Kids Daydreamer Comforter Set.

Available in navy, chambray blue, light pink, and lavender, these comforters are easily paired with unicorns or dinosaurs but subdued enough to give everyone plenty of flexibility when dinosaurs and unicorns are “for babies.” 

Pottery Barn’s Daydreamer comforter is hand quilted and filled with 250-gram weight polyester batting. The classic grid pattern keeps the filling from shifting no matter what your little one throws its way, and parents will be happy to know it’s machine washable and dryer friendly, so keeping it clean is a breeze no matter how many forts it’s dragged into. This comforter set is all-season, and the comforter and shams reverse to a contrasting back.

Pieces Included: 1 comforter, 2 shams (1 sham for twin) | Material: 50% cotton, 50% lyocell | Sizes: Twin-full/queen

The Company Store Jersey Knit Comforter Set

The Company Store


What’s Great About It

  • Jersey-knit cotton feels like a well-loved tee

  • Resistant to wrinkles

  • Lightweight yet cozy for year-round use

  • Machine washable and dryer friendly

For teens, coolness counts, even when it comes to their bedding. And there’s probably nothing cooler on the planet than a vintage tee—except maybe a comforter set that feels like one. 

Designed to feel just as soft and broken in as their favorite tee, this comforter set is breathable and wrinkle resistant. It’s made with jersey-knit cotton, and it’s stuffed with polyester fiberfill. And when your teen finally puts their phone down long enough to get some shut-eye, they’ll be warm and cozy without overheating. 

Lightweight yet cozy enough for year-round use, this comforter set includes a full comforter and two shams, and you can choose from 12 teen-approved colors, including cloud blue, navy, orange, or lavender. All comforters reverse to the same color, shams feature an envelope closure, and the set is machine washable and dryer friendly.

Pieces Included: 1 comforter, 2 shams (1 sham for twin) | Material: Cotton, polyester fiberfill | Sizes: Twin/twin XL-king

The Bottom Line

The Sleep Number Classic Down Alternative is our Best Overall pick. The hypoallergenic down-alternative fill and cotton sateen fabric offer cloud-like softness night after night. Plus, the sewn-through construction prevents the fill from shifting throughout the night. If you’re still not convinced, be sure to take advantage of Sleep Number’s 100-night guarantee. 

For a more budget-friendly option, the Bare Home Comforter Set is just the right weight for all-season use and comes in over two dozen color options. 

Tips for Choosing the Right Comforter Set

Material

When you’re shopping for a comforter set, one of the first things to consider is the material—both the material of the shell and the filling. 

As you might have guessed, comforter sets come in a wide variety of fabrics. Linen, cotton, microfiber, silk, you name it, it exists. So deciding what you want is a good place to start. Remember that cotton, linen, and bamboo are light, breathable choices for the summer months, flannel and faux fur are good picks for wintry weather, and silk is a good temperature regulator, so it’s a good all-season option. 

Beyond the fabric shells, comforter fillings are another important consideration. The most common fillings for comforters are polyester fiber fill and down. While polyester is usually machine washable and easy to care for, the same can’t be said for down. Additionally, down comforters can stir up allergies, so you might want to steer clear if you like to breathe freely while you sleep. 

Weight

The weight of a comforter is another important buying consideration, and there’s no mystery here. A lightweight comforter is your best bet if you’re looking for a comforter set for the warmer months or you normally sleep hot. If you’re looking for a new comforter set to grace your bed over in the fall and winter, or you tend to sleep cold—a heavier-weight down comforter should be on your list of must-haves. 

What’s Included

When shopping for comforter sets, you’ll also find that some only come with the comforter and matching shams, while others come with everything you need to outfit your bed. In addition to a comforter and shams, more comprehensive comforter sets may include bed sheets, a bed skirt, and even decorative pillows. The thing to keep in mind here is that three-piece comforter sets may be more affordable, while larger sets may hit your bank balance a little harder.  

Care

Sleeping is dirty business, so when shopping for a comforter set, don’t forget to consider the care instructions. Typically cotton, bamboo, and flannel are relatively easy to maintain, whereas a silk comforter (and many high-end comforters) are usually not machine washable, so cleaning and maintenance could be costly over the long term. 

Questions and Answers

What comforter fabric keeps you cool? 

“Natural fabrics and materials like cotton, linen, and bamboo are the best options for staying cool while you sleep,” says Gordon. She adds that bamboo is great at keeping you cool because its “natural fibers create tiny air pockets that help regulate your body temperature no matter what the season. Plus, it helps keep moisture away from the skin, [ultimately] promoting more restful sleep.”

What is the best way to clean a comforter?

The best way to clean a comforter is to follow the care instructions as outlined by the manufacturer. If your comforter is machine washable, then be sure to note the water temperature and drying instructions. If it’s dry-clean only, then be sure to do so. 

If you use a top sheet, you can probably get away with laundering your comforter every month. You might even be able to extend the time between washings to every three months.

If you don’t use a top sheet, and your body makes nightly contact with your comforter, you might consider matching the laundry schedule for your sheets and pillowcases.  

Do you need a different comforter for warm weather?

All-season comforters are a one-and-done purchase that can get you through cold winters and sultry summers alike. If your comforter isn’t suitable for year-round use, however, you’ll need to swap them out seasonally.

Beyond looking for comforter sets that are lightweight and made of natural materials such as cotton or bamboo, Gordon suggests “choosing a comforter with a low fill power rating so it is not too heavy or thick to further help regulate your body temperature while you’re sleeping.” 

What is the difference between a comforter and a duvet?

“A comforter is a quilted or sewn-through bedding item filled with down, feather, polyester, or other material that provides warmth,” says Gordon. Comforters are typically available in an assortment of colors and prints, so they’re ready to use right out of the packaging and don’t need to be covered. 

Duvets are typically plain, no-frills inserts that go into a duvet cover. While duvets are usually white, people can use duvet covers to add some personality and color to their bedding.  

Why Trust Southern Living

This article was written by Sharon Brandwein, Certified Sleep Science Coach and freelance commerce writer. Over the last five years, Sharon has written product reviews and roundups for a variety of online publishers. To curate this list of the best comforter sets, Sharon considered style, fabrication, fill materials, and care requirements. For expert insight, she spoke to Hafiz Shariff, sleep expert and founder of Owl + Lark, as well as Isabella Gordon, a Sleep Science Coach and co-founder of Sleep Society. Southern Living Commerce Writer Moriah Mason also contributed to this article. 



Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *